Search DCH site A A A A Register for updates

Register for updates Affiliate and Donate What You Can Do

Labour Party Conference, 2006 Report

Labour conference backs 'Fourth Option' for third year
Trade unions backed motion from 15 Constituency Labour Parties at Labour's conference Sept 2006 (photo Andrew Wiard www.reportphotos.co.uk) Three years running the Labour Party conference has overwhelmingly voted for direct investment. "Conference again calls on government to provide the 'fourth option' of direct investment to council housing as a matter of urgency." Read statement from Austin Mitchell MP, text of Composite 10, mover's speech and press.
Ministers tried to get the motion withdrawn but 15 Constituency Labour Parties, backed by the trade unions, insisted on a vote which went 2:1 against the government. In an attempt to persuade delegates the Labour Party National Executive Committee also put a statement to conference. Tenants and trade unionists prepare to leaflet Labour conference delegates (photo Simon Clark www.eyebox.net) This pledged that the sub-group set up by the National Policy Forum would be addressing the issues "We recognise the decisions conference has taken on the issue of social housing in 2004 and 2005". "We believe that bringing all social housing up to decent standards is central to Labour's Sustainable Communities agenda." "In particular the group is exploring ways of creating a level playing field in the funding for social housing, between those with ALMOs or Housing Associations, and those without." "… we await its conclusions early next year" Read pre-conference bulletin and conference report.

Moving Composite 10: "Are Ministers listening?"
window.status='Sue Howes (photo Andrew Wiard www.reportphotos.co.uk)' Sue Howes moved Composite 10 from Gravesham CLP. She said:

"Chair, Conference. Sue Howes, Gravesham CLP. Proposing Composite 10. This is my first party conference and the first time I've spoken in public.
I was brought up in a council house; both my parents and Nan are still council tenants. Council housing makes sense. It's cheaper to build, manage and maintain than the private alternatives. It provides greater security for tenants and lower rents and charges. And, more importantly, council tenants get to elect their landlord and have a much greater chance of holding them to account.
15 CLPs submitted contemporary motions calling for the 'Fourth Option'. We want to stand by our tenants who want improvements without the risks of privatisation.
We're facing a growing housing crisis and the private market just can't solve it.
There's a lot of hype about home ownership and there's a deliberate attempt to make people feel inadequate unless they own a home but many don't want to and millions could never afford to. If we hadn't thought of the idea of decent, affordable, secure and accountable public housing then we'd have to invent council housing today.
It's no wonder that the vast majority of council tenants want to remain with the council rather than get privatised. But, rightly, they also want their homes and estates improved.
Ministers keep telling everyone they're in favour of choice - what about choice for council tenants? I'm not going to go through the detailed financial arguments for the 'Fourth Option' - I haven't got time. They are well documented in the House of Commons Council Housing group's report (HOLD IT UP) and the new pamphlet 'Case for Council Housing in 21st Century Britain".
The key facts are that governments have been systematically disinvesting - robbing - council housing. If all the money that belongs to council housing is re-invested there is more than enough to fund an 'investment allowance' which is at the core of the 'Fourth Option'.
We want a 'level playing field'. If the Treasury is prepared to write off debt for councils who privatise their homes then why not for councils who retain them?
Nearly 3 million council tenants in 200 authorities across England, Scotland and Wales would benefit from the 'Fourth Option'.
There are more than 100 authorities who have decided to retain their homes, more than 50 authorities who have set up ALMOs (they will face the same issues after their five year contract runs out) and 44 like Gravesham where tenants are due to be balloted on privatisation.
We all need the 'Fourth Option' to guarantee a long term secure future for council housing.
Ministers have lost the argument. They've lost it with tenants; they've lost it with many councils and councillors, with the trade union movement and with MPs.
So now Ministers are trying to counter pose building new homes against their commitment on Decent Homes. That just isn't acceptable. Last year the government made a clear election manifesto commitment. They said "By 2010 we will ensure that all social tenants benefit from a decent, warm home with modern facilities."
Governments can't make and break key manifesto promises and still expect to get re-elected.
All of us are in favour of building new homes and it would make sense to enable councils to start building first class council homes that a new generation of tenants could be proud of.
This is a fundamental debate. Ministers say they believe in choice but councils spend literally millions promoting privatisation. Despite this tenants still vote NO but when councils don't get the result they want - like in Sefton - they re-ballot. It's a democratic scandal.
Privatisation is not just bad value for money but it leaves tenants with less security and higher rents and charges.
As Adam Sampson from Shelter pointed out on Sunday night, "many of these so-called 'not for profit' Registered Social Landlords are dominated by the banks and act as commercial concerns who are more interested in building for sale than looking after tenants who rent".
In 2004 there was an 8:1 vote at conference in support of a level playing field for council housing. Last year Gravesham seconded the motion on the 'Fourth Option'. The conference chair described the vote as 'almost unanimous'.
Are Ministers listening? Earlier this year we were told that a working group was set up by the Sustainable Communities Commission to address the terms of the 2004 conference decision. We were told it would report to this conference but it hasn't. The NEC states that a report is expected early next year but nothing is defined
We've had all sorts of promises and assurances from senior Ministers: Stephen Byers, John Prescott and others. We don't want promises that get broken or ignored.
I hope conference will express its overwhelming support and that Ministers will finally respect the democratic wishes of council tenants and of the party on the third attempt.
I move this motion"

Read report of 2005 Labour Party Conference
Lively DCH Fringe Meeting
Meeting platform (photo Simon Clark www.eyebox.net)
Delegates and tenants from Manchester came to hear MPs Austin Mitchell and Michael Meacher, trade unionists Gail Cartmail (Amicus), Pete Alleson (T&G) and Neil Andrews (UCATT). MPs Frank Dobson and Jon Cruddas sent apologies. The meeting was chaired by Alan Walter from DCH. Read pre-conference bulletin.

DCH bulletin distributed to Labour conference delegates

2005 Conference Report
"Labour leaders lose housing vote"
Delegates voting 2005 (photo Simon Clark www.eyebox.net) Labour's conference "agreed unaminously" to demand the government provide the 'fourth option' for council housing. The motion came top in the constituency section's priorities ballot and the vote (Sept 29) was even bigger than the 8:1 majority last year. Delegates also voted overwhelmingly against a pro government motion which tried to give Ministers some comfort.
See press coverage and read full report of 2005 conference including speeches, photos, etc.
Over 130 people packed into a standing room only DCH fringe meeting to hear MPs Austin Mitchell, Frank Dobson and Nick Brown along with Jack Dromey (T&G), other union leaders and tenants.
There was a positive response from councillors and trade unions for the proposal to organise a national Lobby of Parliament on Feburary 8. The campaign is consulting local authorities, trade unions and the Parliamentary group to co-ordinate transport to London to bring tenants, trade unionists and councillors from across the country to lobby their MPs. Let us know what you arrange from your area...
During the conference more than 250 delegates signed the open letter to John Prescott 'A Promise Is A Promise'.

Trade unions backed motion from 15 Constituency Labour Parties at Labour's conference Sept 2006 (photo Andrew Wiard www.reportphotos.co.uk)

Tenants and trade unionists prepare to leaflet Labour conference delegates (photo Simon Clark www.eyebox.net)

Austin Mitchell MP and Alan Walter, chair DCH (photo Simon Clark www.eyebox.net)

Gail Cartmail, AMICUS Assistant General Secretary and Alan Walter, chair DCH (photo Simon Clark www.eyebox.net)

Read PDFs Defend Council Housing
Contact Us
Useful External Links